Punk Rock is a Trauma Industrial Complex
Abstract
Punk Rock is a Trauma Industrial Complex
Abstract
Jan Rapp is here to speak with us about Masks. Masks can be found as artifacts in all the corners of the globe and have been used for a variety of purposes. They are used to this day for a variety of purposes. In a few days time we will see the streets lined with Captain Americas, zombies, infants dressed as pumpkins, Fortnite characters, Disney Princesses, Harry Potters, Hulks, little Batmen and Jokers.
The purpose of a mask is to hide one's identity to take on the identity of another. This experience, however, means that two identities are being represented in one body, that of the mask wearer and the illustration of the spirit or identity the mask represents. For example, in the 1994 Jim Carey classic the Mask, Stanley Ipkiss, a timid man experiencing a losing streak, puts on an ancient mask that contains the spirit of the Norse trickster Loki. By changing his face, Ipkiss is empowered by Loki and transforms into a supernatural Cassanova with a vibe similar to Bugs Bunny. He is charming and confident, funny and extroverted. The Mask changes his life.
So it was In 1890, the Ghost Dance ceremony was incorporated into numerous indigenous American belief systems. The ceremony as it spread through the Indigenous American world, involved elaborate costumes and masks. According to its originator, the spiritual leader Wovoka, the dance would reunite the living with the spirits of the dead who would help the living fight westward colonial expansion and bring peace, prosperity and unity to the Indigenous peoples of the region. The ceremony was first practiced by the Northern Paiute people of Nevada in 1889. The practice was adopted quickly in the western United States from Oklahoma to California. Different tribes would put their own spin on the practice and emphasize select aspects of the ritual. The Ghost Dance is still practiced today by the Caddo people of Oklahoma. The Ghost Dance has been accredited by Lakota Sioux elders for influencing their resistance towards colonization and environmental destruction in their lands.
So in both our western colonial world as well as in the natural spiritual world of the historical indigenous American, the mask can reanimate our individual or culture’s damaged hearts. It is a rare moment in which all entities can assemble as one; by taking on the personality of another, our own Egos are damaged in the process as we must sacrifice an element of our individuality in order to take on the form of another. This ego death is perhaps why we love Halloween so much; we let go of our socially constructed identities for an evening to connect with the spirits of others. How ironic that such a “spooky” holiday can also bring us closer together through mutual affection for spirits.
This is merely my introduction to Jan Rapp’s Mask Making Proffesional Practice. Rapp is an art educator that needs not to wear a mask as she is a spirit, a legend, on her own right. A quick google search of her name will let you know she’s been in this art teaching game for well over a decade and her art practice is invested and interested in the natural world. She is also a “behind the scenes” member of our non-proit whose efforts consistently go unsung.
Until tonight. Please welcome the one and only Jan Rapp, a spirit whose heart burns like a furnace, a woman with no need for a mask.
Hasta la Victoria Siempre,
Jack Turnbull
I have had a great thrill teaching this class and from what my student have told me first hand, I can only assume that they did too. I get great pleasure in hearing the students say “That was fun” referring to research projects, students whom at the beginning of the term I made the unfair mental assumption were students not interested in school. And the work speaks for itself; you don’t have to take my word for it. Look at our research posters. Does this look fun?
My favorite thing to do is to do research, find research that blows my mind, and then share that research which in turn blows other peoples minds. And so - right now, I want to attempt to blow your minds. Students, take note: being a teacher and watching peoples heads explode is an adrenaline rush 1,000 more satisfying than any video game or illicit substance you might get access to in the future.
I have a question: please be honest, because there is no judgement upon how you answer. Do you all think that we, as a community, can turn Cape Cod into a proverbial “Garden of Eden?”
So - my big lesson to you all is that history is not linear and neither is culture. Yes, there is a technological linear advancement, but sometimes these advancements are drawbacks in disguise. Take, for example, the invention of the Atom Bomb. Or to a lesser extent, the invention of the printing press which enabled Martin Luther to distribute his 95 thesis, which split the Christian Church in 2 and started wars and conflicts that continued for hundreds of years. To think of it another way, when a war occurs, there is a winner and a loser. Usually, things get better for the winner and things get worse for the loser. History is not linear and neither is culture.
This means, that hypothetically, there were moments in the past, even in the ancient past, that were way more prosperous than 2023 and it means there were moments in the past that were way worse than 2023.
So let’s think about the date October 12th, 1492, when Columbus sailed near a small Archipelago of hundreds of small islands near the Caribbean Sea. He was petitioned by the Spanish crown to find a new route to the Asian Markets. In exchange, he was to be made governor of any new lands discovered and receive 10% of any revenues gained in them. It was on one of these Bahamas islands that he came in contact with the Lycayan, a branch of the Taino, the indigenous people of the region, an Arawak-speaking people, their population at the time being estimated to have reached some 2 million, which is roughly 1/4th of today’s New York City.
In his journal, Columbus noted that the Taino were “HEALTHY AND HAPPY” and that “Antisocial Crimes were virtually Unknown”. He described their islands as “earthly paradise, a land of riches and abundance, where the native peoples led lives of simplicity and freedom similar to those enjoyed by Adam and Even in the Biblical Garden of Eden.”
Now … here on Cape Cod, we are technically an island. We don’t have the abundance of resources the Taino had because we don’t have the rainforest, a place where you can wake up and start walking around collecting fruits off trees and medicinal herbs from the ground. We have New England in February, and it’s pretty hard to grow stuff.
But we do have a year round population that is under 200,000. We also have a different type of abundance. We have access to technology and materials that the Taino of 1492 would look at and think was some type of proverbial witchcraft (and when you think about how the internet works economically, the Taino of 1492 have a point). We have so many materials that the majority of people don’t even know how they’re made, what they’re made of or where they came from.
So if the Taino can create a society with an abundance of resources and is so peaceful that antisocial crime is pretty much unheard of …a proverbial “garden of eden” … why can’t we? Why can’t we build, what John Winthrop called “a city upon a hill, the eyes of all people upon us”?
I am defining being Woke as "to expose the horrid injustices that lie at the heart of our banal, screen addicted world." To be Woke is the opposite of being asleep. It is to be aware of injustice and therefore in a state of panic at best, nightmarish hell-scape at worst.
Therefore, Wokeism is not necessarily politically Right or Left in theory, although it is frequently associated with the Left.
On the Left, the term often pairs with Critical Race Theory, Climate Change anxiety, Income Inequality, Capitalism in general, Indigenous Resistance, Decolonization, Gender and Identity Politics, etc.
But on the Right, while people may not use the exact terminology of being "Woke" as it is associated with Liberal and Left leaning circles, it is still present in the way information is presented. For example, the QAnon phenomenon presents the conspiracy theory that a Satanic, Cannibalistic Pedophile Cabal conspired against Donald Trump while he was in office. The way this conspiracy theory is often presented is by someone who is "Woke" to this fact, trying to awaken the American brainwashed public. While one hears a faint echo of reality in this conspiracy theory (Jeffrey Epstein and his many pals), it tells volumes that, like a game of telephone, the conspiracy theory spirals down into deeper depths of depravity each time it is told. It tells even more volumes that Donald Trump himself ran in many circles with Jeffrey Epstein. It is also interesting that the right have an anxiety about a cabal of rich people pulling the strings of our society; a suspicion found on both the Right and the Left and a place where some very significant Vanguardism can be performed. I only stop this common ground when the right presents this anxiety of income inequality through the lens of identity politics. For example, Kanye West complaining about a Jewish Cabal holding him back and bullying him. Is there a Cabal of rich people who have major influence on politics and culture? Yes. Are some of them Jewish? Sure. But that does not mean all Jewish people are exploitative Capitalists who make sure the country only works for them and nobody else. Exploiters come in all shapes, sizes, genders, ethnicities, etc. Synagogues get shot up by idiots who listen to people like Kanye West because they take these stereotypes and apply them to entire communities. There is no point in focusing in on one ethnicity when the issue is an issue of class, not ethnicity. This emphasis on identity is a common characteristic of Fascism; the Right in this country is Fascist and even moderate Republicans are flirting with it, but with education and the presentation of some simple economic frameworks, they are not lost causes. Ironically, the right are the people who complain all the time about being held back by identity politics, when their spokespeople are the ones most obsessed with it.
On this particular issue of identity politics, the Liberal class is also not off the hook. Those historically marginalized should be fighting for a more egalitarian world, not for a reckoning. There are definitely liberal bad actors out there looking for Capitalist power, desiring, for once, to be the slave masters as opposed to a world without any slave masters, a vision which they cynically brush off as idealistic. But I am digressing ...
The term Woke is often used pejoratively now, but I for one think it is noble to attempt to expose injustice. It is noble to be critical of our society. But if society is to get better, we must all be more than just critical; we must be radical, which is to say we must change. It is therefore possible to be Woke but not noble.
An example of someone who is woke but not noble would be what is being termed a "doom scroller"; someone who scrolls through social media looking for examples of how awful the world is. This person is ironically woke; they are woke at the sacrifice of their own time actually living on Earth by experiencing a second hand version of it in the form of a glowing box with an Apple on the back, sending what is only very fancy morse code telegrams describing escalating atrocities occurring across the globe. It is great to be informed, but at a certain point one must take action in response to the information gathered. This can take many forms, but one thing that is not taking action is the usage of the majority of ones time doom-scrolling in the first place.
By this definition, to be Woke is more of a narrative framework and less of a political philosophy like say, Marxist-Leninism. However, as a critique, to be Woke can be the beginnings of a political philosophy, the same way Marx's critique of Capitalism in Das Capital is a critique, while The Communist Manifesto is a response to the critiques presented in Das Capital. In this way, one can be a Marxist without being a Communist; you can agree with Marx's critique of Capitalism while disagreeing that Communism as the correct response to this critique.
To follow this analogy to being Woke, it is only a half of an idea. We on the left must stop trying to one up one another in Wokeism, switching our priorities to brainstorming answers to the problems presented by Wokeism. This is a far harder task, which is why you don't see many answers.
People who do take action get critiqued by doom scrollers, who do nothing but critique. For example, Kim Stanley Robinson's "The Ministry of the Future", a masterpiece of a new genre, "Non-Ficiton Science Fiction", is a book that presents possible solutions to the climate crisis in the form of a novel. It is an incredible book, a revolutionary book that gave me so much hope it helped me come out of a depression. Of course, it was critiqued by the Woke Doom Scrollers, who are hilariously paradoxical nihilists. For example, Francis Fukuyama, author of The End of History, panned the book as "ludicrously unrealistic". He may have a good point, he may even be right, but he isn't giving anyone another answer. The review he stated this in is literally called "We're Cooked". He is a woke critic with no answers. Perhaps Robinson is unrealistic, but there is no alternative being presented. To live in a world with no hope for the future is beyond unhealthy. It is the cause of so many problems, both personal and political. Don't ask a drug addict to stop doing drugs if there is no future. Don't ask people to be charitable when there is no future. Don't expect students to study hard in school when there is no future. Don't expect people to work at their soul sucking jobs when there is no future. When there is no future, society falls apart, so even if Robinson's presented solutions are unrealistic, they must be taken as the first step in a praxis of imagination; So, ok Fukuyama, you may have a point, but then what do you do? Just accept hedonism like a coward? This is no way to live.
Another recent example were the two young activists who threw a soup can at a Vincent Van Gogh painting. While I did not like this act because I am an artist myself who is very fond of Van Gogh, I do not denounce these activists because they are trying. Their action should be placed in a discussion of praxis; this soup can stunt is a good first step, but we can learn from the act that it alienates many people and actually turns people away from the cause of climate change. Perhaps a more direct and effective act would be to simply blow up a gas pipeline (please don't blow up a pipeline. You hear that NSA? I'm not advocating for blowing up a pipeline.), or how about throwing Campbell soup at King Salman of Saudi Arabia, who directly profits from fossil fuel production? I understand that these acts are far more difficult to carry out due to massive security issues. Kings and pipelines are heavily protected and not available to the public. But everything that is worth doing is difficult.
The point is that the Campbell Soup Can throwers are heroes because they are doing way more than any Woke Doomscroller who simply sits on their ass posting articles on their Twitter feeds about how messed up the world is. Yes, we all know how messed up the world is. We may disagree as to how exactly it is messed up, but everyone in the world can agree that it is. Right and Left, we are all Woke now. We must become post-woke. The era of critique must come to an end and the era of brainstorming solutions must begin.
Last spring, I posted a blog entry entitled "The Ghost of Greenberg" that viewed 20th century American Art through an economic lens and then traced that history to my personal undergraduate experience at RISD. Aesthetics and stylistic trends can be traced back to supply and demand issues; in the case of the 20th century New York art market, one reason old world masterpieces went out of vogue for the avant-garde was because there is a finite amount of old world masterpieces. On the contrary, avant-garde work is produced today, so there is an on-going supply for these works. It makes, therefore, economic sense to champion contemporary work over antiques as there is more supply and you can therefore make more profit in the market.
I then made the argument that Clement Greenberg champions the avant-garde in the form of Abstract Expressionism, specifically Jackson Pollack, whom he called the greatest living painter of his day. Greenberg believed that form is higher and more intellectual than content. But I critiqued this by saying that this attitude is sort of an absurd statement and that it is ultimately subjective. It's like comparing apples and oranges, some people like content and some people prefer form, but to argue that one is superior to another is kind of silly. In fairness, focusing on form to the point of abandoning content was avant-garde and novel. Pollock, De Kooning, Guston (oh man do I love Philip Guston; hopefully I'll write a blog post just about him.) did contribute to the pantheon of painting in a new way. My objection is to the hierarchy their discoveries created in the real world, specifically, a school of people focusing on form looking down on people who are more interested in content. For what it is worth, my opinion is both content and form should be studied as the best art usually addresses both.
From here, I told a first hand anecdotal history of my experience of this schism and its consequences for the community. Comparing RISD student's reactions to Bush's invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan to the student reactions during the Viet Nam war of the 1960s and 70s was a moment of focus, for example.
I did not intend to write a follow up to this blog post, but some kind peers of mine wrote to me in response to my posting. They informed me that they related to what I wrote and then supplied me to some internet links which they thought I'd find illuminating. These links were articles on the political connections between abstract expressionism and the CIA during the Cold War. I'll put one here by Michael R. McBride that is brief and articulate. A quick google search of "Jackson Pollack CIA" brings up lots of articles on the topic from a variety of sources, including the New Yorker. Furthermore, in Harvard Professor Louis Menhand's latest book, "The Free World", it is exposed that it was not just abstract expressionism which was sponsored and monitored by the CIA, but a full cornucopia of news outlets, magazines, movie studios, museums, television stations, etc. For example,
"In fact, debriefing was a widespread Agency ("the Agency" is in reference to the CIA) practice with Americans who went overseas. Major news organizations, including TIME, CBS, and The New York Times, cooperated with the CIA for many years, in some instances providing cover jobs for CIA agents. And the Agency planted agents in overseas organizations, and not only in the journals, such as Encounter, published by the Congress for Cultural Freedom. The Paris Review was founded in 1953 as a cover for its coeditor, Peter Matthiessen, who was a CIA agent. He could report back on what he heard in Paris.
Louis Menhand, "The Free World", pg. 710
This exposes our philosophy of freedom and demystifies the illusion of Abstract Expressionism being without ideology; to know the hand of the state was promoting and subsidizing specific artists, communication centers and news outlets destroys the argument that said artists and individuals rose to notoriety through some type of democratic meritocracy. The state gave a helping hand to Abstract Expressionism, a vision that just so happens to be the exact opposite of what the state's ideological and literal enemy, the USSR, was.
At this point, it is interesting to compare and contrast Soviet artwork and the artwork of post-WWII United States.
PT. 1 Liberalism and Slavery
Let's start by clearing something up. Classically, to be liberal means to rule by compromise. If you google "Liberal definition", the Oxford dictionary will give you this first definition.
1. Willing to respect or accept behavior or opinions different than one's own; open to new ideas.
Which is a nice way of saying you rule by compromise.
Liberalism can be good or bad depending on what the new idea you are open to is. If the new idea is LGBTQ+ practices, it is good to be liberal because said practices have no negative effect on others or the planet. If the new idea is slavery, it is a bad to be liberal.
In today's political realm, it is in vogue for both the left and the right to put down liberals. A lot of these put-downs are justifiable. For example, it was liberalism that enabled slavery for decades in the United States. Pretty much everyone at the time was guilty of enabling slavery. This is because the US slavery industry was cotton and pretty much everyone wore cotton. While southern plantation owners performed the actual genocide, anyone who wore cotton was financing it and enabling it. While some people may have worn cotton but did not have respect for slave owners, they accepted and FINANCED the practices of slave owners. Liberalism.
The Liberalism got even more sinister after the Civil War. In 1862, President Lincoln signed the District of Columbia Compensated Emancipation Act. The law prohibited slavery in the district, forcing 900-odd slaveholders to free their slaves, with the federal government paying owners an average of about $300 (equivalent to $8000 today). The slaves themselves got $0. Lincoln was willing to respect and accept the behavior and opinions of slave owners, but not slaves themselves, a terrible example of Liberalism for the whites, Racism and Fascism for the blacks.
As a society, money and convenience is what drives our decisions, not moral compasses. Our liberal democracy has enabled this. The retort to my accusation that everyone wearing cotton is guilty of financing slavery is "What else were people supposed to wear?" If you are an Existentialist like myself, you understand this is ridiculous and an absurd, Capitalist construct of reality. People could spend more money and wear silk, made from the cocoons of silkworms, an inhumane trade that is not cruelty free, but which does not involve literal backbreaking work performed by human beings and children. The retort to this is "not everyone could afford silk." This is true, but people could simply drop out and wear a barrel with suspenders. The former option is one only available for the super rich, whereas the later means having to stand out as a radical. People could have also worn hemp, whose plant is not thorny and painful to the touch.
This sounds very similar to reasons why people don't get solar panels (super high installation fee), continue to drive cars (buses take longer and are less comfortable), refuse the transformation from gas to green (change is hard, plus you can't sell sun beams or wind, so there is no financial incentive to go green) buy ethically devious products (companies who don't pay their workers living wages often have cheaper products), buy things from Amazon (the most convenient invention to ever exist), buy foods with ingredients that are illegal in other countries (Mountain Dew has Brominated Vegetable Oil, an emulsifier that can cause reproductive and behavioral problems. Its original use was a flame retardant for carpets. This is just one example), the list goes on and on. Most people don't know where their clothes come from, who made them and for what wage. In some cases, slaves still make our clothes. Money and convenience rules our marketplaces, not moral compasses. Some things don't seem to change; you either can't afford to do the right thing or you are labeled as a smug radical.
To be fair, if one goes through their life never compromising with anyone on anything, it is not a very good life. Imagine a friendship, marriage or work environment where nobody compromised on anything. However, love is a loophole out of this sad truth (more on that later).
But on the other hand, if your friend, partner or people in your work environment are slaver owners, it is vital that you stop compromising with that person immediately.
In summation, liberalism gets a bad wrap, but at the same time, if there are fascists or slave owners in your country, you can't compromise with them.
Life is a game in which you need to know when to compromise and when to stand your ground. Sometimes doing either is very hard. Sometimes the right thing to do gets confusing, other times it is inconvenient, or financial suicide, but blatantly obvious.
To end this section, I would like to advocate for reparations for the descendants of slaves. It is only mathematically fair that each household that contains a descendant of a slave would receive AT LEAST $8000 from the US government, the contemporary equivalent in capital to what slave owners received. Descendants of slaves would need to prove their ancestry to avoid corruption, a task that may be hard to perform, but at the same time would help people learn their family history, another vital piece to the puzzle of healing the wounds of the genocide which was the US slave trade. The US government should hire expert researchers to help these descendants at no extra charge.
It may sound corny, but I believe that love knows no compromise. I will argue this position. Once you take a liberal approach to love itself, it is a slippery slope towards slavery and environmental destruction.
To be continued ...